was writing about our class on my blog, and i got this comment ...
"Question:
Do you think the book of lamentations would've been written if there were depression drugs provided back then?
What if God, instead of manna, dropped down Prozac from the sky?
But seriously, it leads to the question of do we provide people a way out of their pain these days, which has been the very thing God uses to drive people towards Him. But maybe the depression drugs only take care of the side effects and that's why there's studies to say that people who take the anti-depression drugs committ suicide? Whatever it is the question begs to be discussed.
Thoughts?"
and so i replied with this post ...
"so, got a comment on what would have happened to lamentations if they'd had drugs back then for depression. and what my thoughts are on medication in this current age. such a complex thing ... here are a few thoughts.
after re-reading lamentations five or six times for this class, i've decided that it wasn't written in the throws of depression. it was written after a group of people watched the total destruction and devastation of their race, culture, and families. much like the people in new orleans and texas right now, i don't think prozac, or any other depression drug could have done much good, nor is it a good option.
if god had rained meds from the sky instead of manna .... well, that's just such an out there question. cuz we all know those stories happened in the time before time (moses, egypt, the entire book of genesis, et al) and so chances are they didn't happen in that way, anyhow. there is no archeological evidence for moses or the exodus, for example. BUT, had god rained down meds instead of manna, i bet the israelites would've spent much more than 40 years wandering in the desert!
as for my take on meds today ... such a personal struggle. i fight daily with depression, described here frequently as my desires to pull my insides onto my outsides. those closest to me have been witness to these attempts to varying degrees. and yet i am not on meds. because for me .... i don't want to walk through life medicated. i'd rather be in this hell and pain than miss out on those moments of experiencing life's joys to the extremes i do.
however, i have friends who have been and/or are currently on meds, and i fully support their decisions. it's a personal choice, ya know. like abortion."
dr. owens asked me to copy this into this site, and so here it is ...
Saturday, September 24, 2005
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
Thanks, Robyn! Great start!
Post a Comment