Wednesday, February 08, 2006

Notes on II Kings

I am writing this straight from my notes without the presence of a Bible.

1:9-14 – King Ahaziah kept sending men to figure out what was going to happen to him since he fell. Each group he sent was killed, but he kept sending more groups.

2:23-25 – Some boys made fun of Elisha so he cursed them and two bears tore them apart.

3:18-25 – The Lord instructed the 3 kings to take over the Moabites by conquering their cities and cutting down their fruit trees, stopping the flow of water and ruining their fields. They did.

3:27 – When the king of Moab realized he was losing the battle, he offered his oldest son as a sacrifice.

6:28-29 – Woman ate her son.

9 and 10:6-7 – Descendants and family of Ahab along with Jezebel to punish her for killing the Lord’s prophets and servants.

10:11 – Killed everyone associated with Ahab.

10:12-14 – Jehu has Ahaziah’s relatives killed on their way to pay respects to the Ahab family.

10:18-27 – Jehu tricks worshipers of Baal and kills them all.

Notes on Judges

I am writing this straight from my notes without the presence of a Bible.

1:6-7 – Adonibezek thumbs and toes (I believe he get them cut off because that’s what he had done to people for punishment)

In chapter one there is a lot of taking of people’s land in general.

4:1-3 – The people sinned so they were given a new ruler whom was violent towards them.

6:3 – The people’s crops were constantly destroyed.

10:8 – People had been oppressed and pleaded with the Lord.

Jephthah’s daughter

12:4-6 – People were made to pronounce a word, if it wasn’t correct, they didn’t belong there so they were killed.

15:3 – Samson and the foxes (I think he set there tails of fire and let them loose into towns)

19:23 – Levite’s Concubine

21:10 – An entire town was killed off except for female virgins

Sunday, February 05, 2006

Lack of Lament in 1 Samuel

these are the places i have found a lack of lament in 1 samuel, and a few places i found lamenting happening ...

1:7-8, 10-11 - hannah weeping because she has no children, sons specifically

2:25 - bad people are bad because god wants to punish them?!

2:30-35 - god tells eli he's removing the family blessing; they will now be cut off, cursed, and die young and out of god's favor; the sign of this will be eli's sons dying on the same day

4:1-2 - philistines beat israelites in war

4:10-11 - is this a different battle, or the same battle from 4:1-2 retold? philistines kill 20,000 this time and capture the ark of the covenant

4:12-13 - elie dies at shock of the loss of covenant and sons

4:19-22 - eli's daughter-in-law is so grieved by these deaths that she goes into labor; dies giving birth

5:1-6 - metaphor ... despite ark being stolen, the philistines' god still bows to yhwh; displacement of foreign gods and ways of worshipping is a kind of terror; result of this ... god strikes at people living in the city, afflicting them with tumors

5:8-12 - no matter where they moved the ark, god struck those people with tumors and sickness; mice ravaged the lands

6:19 - when people don't rejoice, god kills them; they call 70 a great slaughter, even though they've killed 70 times that number in god's name!

7:2 - it says the people of israel "lamented after the lord"

7:10-11 - samuel cried out to god and god helped the israelites kill the philistines

8:10-18 - samuel tells the people the downside to having a king; foreshadowing of the terror that will befall the people

10:27, 11:1-2 - two israelite tribes being tortured by a rival king

11:6-7 - saul's scare tactic to get people to fight with him

11:11-13 - israelites want to kill the amonites that were left over; saul won't let them

12:6-18 - samuel recounts times when god has saved the israelites from harm, but how the people have continually turned from god

13:2-15 - jonathen's army of 1000 defeats some philistines; counter-attack causes israelites to cower; saul offers sacrifice to god instead of waiting for samuel

14:13-15 - jonathen goes to get his sword sharpened w/ his armor bearer; they slaughter 20 or so men and cause panic in the philistine camp

14:20-23 - saul and the rest of the troops join the battle, outnumbering the philistines and slaughtering them all

14:41-46 - the people ransom jonathen from saul, who almost has him killed

14:47-48 - valiantly struck down moab, ammonites, edom, zobah and philistines

15:2-3 - god's punishment; sanctioned genocide of an entire group of people

15:9 - israelites keep what they want as spoils of war

15:32-33 - samuel slaughters agag, king of the amalakites

16:1 - god won't let samuel grieve over saul


17:48-51 - david kills goliath the philistine

17:52-54 - israelites chased the philistines, killing and wounding; then plundered the camp **winning not enough, they had to obliterate

18:5 - david was successful (means he killed and conquered)

18:7 - the women sing a song of joy for the number of men saul and david have killed

18:13-14 - david's success in war and killing was because of god

18:25-27 - david gives saul 100 philistine foreskins in exchange for marriage to saul's daughter

19:8 - more philistine death

22:16-19 - saul killed the priest, the family and the town; all for helping david

23:1-5 - david goes after the philistines

24:4 - god's plot to give david any enemy unto his hands

25:1 - samuel dies; it says all of israel mourned for him

25:37-39 - god kills nabal for not helping david; david takes the man's wife as his own

30:1-2 - the amalakites raided negeb and zukag and carried off the women and children after burning the cities down; v.4 gives evidence of mourning

30:16-17 - david slaughters the amalakites

Friday, February 03, 2006

Review: “Poet as ‘Female Impersonator’: The Image of Daughter Zion as Speaker in Biblical Poems of Suffering” by Barbara Bakke Kaiser

Just short of 20 pages, this article covers the use of female speaker through three passages, one in Jeremiah and two in Lamentations. Kaiser examines the use of the female voice for purposes of expressing “the intensity of [the poet’s] grief.”

On the whole, I found the arguments very well laid-out, and for the most part agreeable to the study we’ve done so far. While the section on Jeremiah 4 wasn’t as useful the first time I read the article, after going back over my notes and Kaiser’s words, I began to realize the conversations we’d had this past Wednesday during our meeting were much more important than I’d felt they were. (And I felt they were incredibly important as we were having them, so you can only imagine how much more so now!)

In the Jeremiah 4 section, Kaiser takes on the idea of woman giving birth. This is a frequent image in the Hebrew writings, and is used to describe “the terror of an impending invasion”; this comparison was a hard one for me to swallow, as giving birth is letting something out of one’s body, not taking a new thing in. However, it was the metaphor of choice for the Hebrew people.

This section of her article takes up the most space, and is incredibly important for the study of women’s portrayal in the Hebrew Bible. As our primary focus of study is, however, on the book of Lamentations, I will spend more time reviewing that portion of her article, although it is the smaller/shorter portion.

In both Lamentations 1 and 2, the poet speaks through the voice of a third-party narrator until “he” comes to a point where using the female voice is the only way to convey the suffering and pain the people are experiencing. Kaiser spends her brief time on these two chapters discussing the portrayal of suffering and anguish through the female as being the only way to accurately capture the pain of Israel after the occupation by Babylon.

A good article, and a great jumping off point for comparative studies of Hebrew Bible portrayal of women.

Wednesday, February 01, 2006

Your No-Limits Panel Abstract

Thought we should have your abstract on the blog. Remember, all I can do is moderate, you have to do all the talking! Registration forms are on line but I will bring some on paper next Weds. also. It looks like since all of you are presenters, you don't have to pay for lunch, but I do! I was going to post the abstract here, but I don't seem to have it on this computer. Will do it later, or one of you can.

Working with the narratives

Going back to a post on 9/28, I see we divided up the Bible this way for looking for the "horrible stories" and incidents. But I'm not sure how much has been done. Would everyone please post your notes! and now we have added Laura, who can pick up Ruth from Naomi if it's not done, and then we gave her Judith (in the Apocrypha) also. But tonight we were reading in Ezekiel and are wondering if we need to be reading all the prophets too, to get all the imagery. I'm feeling like it is time for some categorization and I'm looking for a method to do that here. I'm thinking of threads that would be categories, with everyone adding images that go in that category. Thoughts on that idea? Titles for the categories? Usually I would think of all this as different colored note cards, and I'm trying to translate note cards that are done by one person working in solitude to a corresponding method that pools all our brains and research in a useable way.

Robyn: Genesis and I Samuel
John: Exodus and Joshua
Peg: Numbers and I Kings
Jen: II Kings and Judges
Naomi: Ruth, Esther, and II Samuel

Everyone please go back and read that 9/28 post, to refresh your memories on what we all agreed we're doing!

Winter Retreat Plans

Looks like we can do February 18 -
Start at 10 a.m. thru dinnertime or just before, with plenty of breaks as needed and bringing lunch in -- let's meet in the ASH 301 conference room (Foreign Languages suite) -- we can make coffee, tea, and whatever there, and there's a tiny refrigerator for cold drinks, plus we can bring ice in an ice chest for drinks. Let's decide what we want for food there and then work on a schedule to get the most accomplished with our time.

The good thing about that location is that there are a lot of desks spread out in that hall where we can divide up, comfy chairs in the main area, and then a great conference table with a big white board. And we have the internet and a good printer, and all my reference books handy. Peg has a rehearsal that will take her back across the street to St. M M for an hour and a half, but other than that it looks like we are all available. Everyone should check for sure and then put it in as a definite on your calendar.

We WILL meet on Weds. next week (2/8) since we aren't having the retreat on the 11th, but then we won't meet 2/15, the week with the retreat. Next week (2/8) we will focus on your No Limits panel discussion. Ok with everyone?

Review: The Speaking Voice in the Book of Lamentations

What I noticed the most about this article is the constant use of “he” and “him” when referring to the poet. Lanahan states early in the article that he “will not discuss the authorship of the book,” but by assuming the author is a male I think is crossing that boundary.

When I read through Lamentations, I get a emotional sense that I don’t get when reading other books of the bible. Although with this class we discuss the persona in the book I never put the two together until reading this article. Lanahan states, “If the use of one persona by the poet enriches his intuition, the use of the five personae discernible in Lamentations should of itself deepen and broaden the reader’s grasp of the dynamics of the spiritual experience embodied by the book.”

Although he names the personas different than we have discussed, I agree with how he splits them up. The first two chapters consist of Jerusalem speaking in her own voice with interruptions from what seems to be the poet; Lanahan calls him/her the reporter. The reader can tell the difference in the intensity of the descriptions. The reporter speaks of the city in her past glories and is the one who metaphorically talks of the city as a woman.

Chapters three and four are individual perceptions. Chapter 3 is a defeated solider who once protected the now fallen city. Lanahan labels the voice of Chapter 4 as a bourgeois.

I enjoyed the different view Lanahan gave on the personas by comparing them. The city and the solider mimic each other because they are both in pain. The reporter and the bourgeois mimic each other because they are both outside views. Although the reporter seems to be a little more emotional about what has happened and the bourgeois wishes the pain on others.

Chapter five is a choral voice. It consists of the people of Jerusalem “subsuming each individual persona in an act of prayer which transcends the viewpoints and the inadequacies which the poet perceived and expressed through the first four chapters.”

I found it hard to review on this article because after all that we have discussed and gone through. I was basically rereading everything we have discussed as a group. I think he summarizes the “feeling” of the book quite well.