Just short of 20 pages, this article covers the use of female speaker through three passages, one in Jeremiah and two in Lamentations. Kaiser examines the use of the female voice for purposes of expressing “the intensity of [the poet’s] grief.”
On the whole, I found the arguments very well laid-out, and for the most part agreeable to the study we’ve done so far. While the section on Jeremiah 4 wasn’t as useful the first time I read the article, after going back over my notes and Kaiser’s words, I began to realize the conversations we’d had this past Wednesday during our meeting were much more important than I’d felt they were. (And I felt they were incredibly important as we were having them, so you can only imagine how much more so now!)
In the Jeremiah 4 section, Kaiser takes on the idea of woman giving birth. This is a frequent image in the Hebrew writings, and is used to describe “the terror of an impending invasion”; this comparison was a hard one for me to swallow, as giving birth is letting something out of one’s body, not taking a new thing in. However, it was the metaphor of choice for the Hebrew people.
This section of her article takes up the most space, and is incredibly important for the study of women’s portrayal in the Hebrew Bible. As our primary focus of study is, however, on the book of Lamentations, I will spend more time reviewing that portion of her article, although it is the smaller/shorter portion.
In both Lamentations 1 and 2, the poet speaks through the voice of a third-party narrator until “he” comes to a point where using the female voice is the only way to convey the suffering and pain the people are experiencing. Kaiser spends her brief time on these two chapters discussing the portrayal of suffering and anguish through the female as being the only way to accurately capture the pain of Israel after the occupation by Babylon.
A good article, and a great jumping off point for comparative studies of Hebrew Bible portrayal of women.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment