What I noticed the most about this article is the constant use of “he” and “him” when referring to the poet. Lanahan states early in the article that he “will not discuss the authorship of the book,” but by assuming the author is a male I think is crossing that boundary.
When I read through Lamentations, I get a emotional sense that I don’t get when reading other books of the bible. Although with this class we discuss the persona in the book I never put the two together until reading this article. Lanahan states, “If the use of one persona by the poet enriches his intuition, the use of the five personae discernible in Lamentations should of itself deepen and broaden the reader’s grasp of the dynamics of the spiritual experience embodied by the book.”
Although he names the personas different than we have discussed, I agree with how he splits them up. The first two chapters consist of Jerusalem speaking in her own voice with interruptions from what seems to be the poet; Lanahan calls him/her the reporter. The reader can tell the difference in the intensity of the descriptions. The reporter speaks of the city in her past glories and is the one who metaphorically talks of the city as a woman.
Chapters three and four are individual perceptions. Chapter 3 is a defeated solider who once protected the now fallen city. Lanahan labels the voice of Chapter 4 as a bourgeois.
I enjoyed the different view Lanahan gave on the personas by comparing them. The city and the solider mimic each other because they are both in pain. The reporter and the bourgeois mimic each other because they are both outside views. Although the reporter seems to be a little more emotional about what has happened and the bourgeois wishes the pain on others.
Chapter five is a choral voice. It consists of the people of Jerusalem “subsuming each individual persona in an act of prayer which transcends the viewpoints and the inadequacies which the poet perceived and expressed through the first four chapters.”
I found it hard to review on this article because after all that we have discussed and gone through. I was basically rereading everything we have discussed as a group. I think he summarizes the “feeling” of the book quite well.
Wednesday, February 01, 2006
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment